The Relationship between Tourette’s Syndrome and Infections

BACKGROUND

Gilles de la Tourette’s syndrome (TS), a tic disorder, is characterized by multiple motor and vocal tics, which wax and wane over time [1]. Epidemiological studies have revealed that TS is relatively common (2.9–5.2 cases per 10,000) and more prevalent in boys [2]. TS is considered a multi-factorial condition; Recent studies revealed that also environmental factors are involved: Infectious agents like group A β haemolytic streptococcal infections seem to be a contributing factor to neuropsychiatric and movement disorders [3]. In addition to the infectious hypothesis for TS, it has been proposed that the involvement of the immune system could be a key component contributing to tic disorders. Beside others, increased levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines [4] and auto-antibodies against basal ganglia have been identified, but are discussed controversially [5, 6]. Also a neurotransmitter dysbalance involving dopaminergic [7] and serotonergic abnormalities has been reported in TS patients [8]. Another probable mechanism for the influence of infections on the cerebral immune balance could be the activation of the tryptophan catabolism via infectious agents and pro-inflammatory cytokines. Tryptophan breakdown leads to neuroactive metabolites that can influence the neurotransmitter balance [9]. Especially in microglia, which are the resident innate immune cells of the brain, tryptophan gets degraded to serotonin and to other products of this metabolism [10], which function either as a NMDA-receptor agonist or antagonist and control the neurotransmitter availability [11]. So far, an imaging study of Behen et al. [12] has identified that in TS there is an abnormal tryptophan metabolism in the cortical and subcortical area. These results are in line with plasma kynurenine levels, that have been shown to be elevated in TS [13]. However, these findings are still controversial in literature. Hoekstra et al. [14] observed an unaltered kynurenine pathway in patients with tic disorders.

Taken this together, TS is a chronic relapsing disorder that can be associated with marked impairment and disability. Although clinical care has improved, a significant number of patients fail to respond adequately or experience intolerable side effects to available treatment options. This review summarizes recent findings related to this topic and integrates available data into a common pathophysiological model. Until now, many questions regarding the association of TS and infections are still unresolved. Discussion continues whether infectious agents and resulting neuroinflammation are an underling cause or a resulting condition in TS.

The purpose of this review is to highlight our new insights into the pathophysiology of TS. We focus on the mechanisms of how infectious agents influence immune parameters, tryptophan metabolism and the resulting neurotransmitter availability. And what strategies result from this underling neuroinflammation for future treatment options for TS? The different levels of dysfunction in TS are illustrated in Fig. (1).

INFECTIONS AND TOURETTE’S SYNDROME

The ethiology of TS is considered to be multi-factorial. In the past years research has focused on infections as a possible contributing factor to the disease or at least to a subgroup of TS patients. It has been observed that children with streptoccoal infections can develop movement disorders such as Sydenham’s chorea. These specific movement abnormalities with the clinical phenotype of poststreptococcal tics and obsessive–compulsive disorders are termed pediatric autoimmune neuropsychiatric disorders associated with streptococcal infection (PANDAS) [3].

PANDAS are characterized by the following criteria: 1. prepubertal onset; 2. chronic tic disorder or obsessive–compulsive disorder; 3. sudden periods of severe exacerbations (‘‘saw tooth’’)—relapsing-remitting course; 4. temporal association of onset and one or more exacerbations with clinical evidence of a streptococcal infections; 5. the presence of subtle neurological findings such as reduced fine motor coordination or increased motor hyperactivity (but not overt chorea) [15]. However, comparing epidemiological studies and case reports on PANDAS reveals that there is no consistent use of these criteria [16]. Therefore the PANDAS concept itself remains controversial. Like in other post-streptococcal diseases auto-antibodies seem to be involved in the pathology. Also the detection of elevated levels of antibodies to the caudate nucleus and putamen in patients with tic-type hyperkinesias supports the association of the striate area in disease development and provides evidence of the autoimmune nature of the process [17, 18]. In addition to streptococci, several other infectious agents have been proposed to play an essential role in the pathogenesis of TS. Two case reports revealed that Mycoplasma pneumoniae might be associated with tic symptoms [19, 20]. This assumption was strengthened by a study that compared 29 Tourette patients to healthy controls regarding the Mycoplasma infection rates. The study found significantly more elevated antibody titers against Mycoplasma pneumoniae in TS patients as compared to controls [21]. Furthermore, an association between herpes simplex virus 1 and the exacerbation of tics was stated [22]. Also an acute infection with Borrelia burgdorferi presenting as TS was reported [23]. Our own group also identified infectious agents as contributing factors in TS: A significantly higher rate of TS patients had elevated antibody titers against Chlamydia trachomatis as compared to controls and trend towards a higher prevalence in the Tourette’s group was shown for Toxoplasma gondii [24].

Unitl now, none of these infectious agents has been linked consistently with TS. Thus a hypothesis is that infections do not directly cause symptoms of the disease, instead they could contribute to TS by triggering an immune response. Therefore the observations of a dysbalanced immune system will be discussed for TS.

IMMUNE PARAMETERS IN TOURETTE’S SYNDROME AND POSSIBLE UNDERLYING MECHANISMS OF THE ASSOCIATION OF TS AND INFECTIOUS AGENTS

In TS patients nonspecific markers of immune activation have been found to be elevated: The parameter neopterin serves as a biomarker of cell-mediated immunity. It is produced by human monocytes/macrophages during Th1-type immune responses, after stimulation with interferon-γ. Increased levels of neopterin have been observed in association with several autoimmune diseases [25, 26]. Also in TS, neopterin levels at baseline were elevated in patients compared to healthy controls [13]. Another marker is c-reactive protein (CRP), which is an acute-phase protein. It gets secreted mainly in the liver and is modulating inflammatory responses, although the exact mechanism remains controversial. Luo et al. tried to identify a biomarker from patients with serologically defined PANDAS. The authors observed that at baseline, patients demonstrated significantly higher levels of D8/17-reactive cells (a marker ofrheumatic fever) and neopterin, compared with control subjects,but there was no consistent pattern of change when exacerbation time points were compared with baseline or follow-up time points. Unlike neopterin levels, a comparison of CRP levels for patients versus control subjects at baseline indicated no significant difference between TS and controls [27].

Also cytokines have been proposed to be involved in TS. Leckmann et al. found that interleukin (IL)-12 and tumor necrosis factor alpha concentrations at baseline were elevated in patients compared with control subjects. Both of these markers were further increased during periods of symptom exacerbation [4].

Also other immunologic studies of early-onset OCD and tic disorders have found and focused on the link between newly acquired streptococcal infections and symptom exacerbations [15, 27, 28] and the presence of potentially pathogenic antineural antibodies [29]. However, it remains controversial which parallels can be drawn from peripheral cytokines to processes in the central nervous system (CNS). It is known that peripheral cytokines influence brain cells through various mechanisms such as passive transport into the CNS, second messengers and active transport during pathological conditions [30, 31]. In some patients with TS, Bos-Veneman et al. showed that they have decreased serum immunoglobulin (Ig) G3, and possibly also IgM levels, though only few patients had fully expressed Ig immunodeficiency as compared to controls [32].

One explanation of how an altered immune balance caused by infectious agents could contribute to psychiatric symptoms is the ‘kindling hypothesis’, which is used to convey the conceptof the development of persistent hypersensitivity to a given stimulus. While regularly a certain stimulus is mandatory for the initiation of the immune response, i.e. the release of cytokines and other mediators of immune activation, kindling is associated with an increased release of cytokines after re-exposure to the same stimulus - or a weaker stimulus is necessary for the same amount of activation [33].

So, is the connection between infectious agents and immune system relevant for disease pathology? New acquired or chronic neurotrophic infections can influence the immune balance and cause neuroinflammation and/or persistent immune changes. The question is how these immune changes might contribute to clinical symptoms?

Therefore the characteristics of neuroinflammtion need to be taken into consideration:

Inflammation in the brain is characterized by activation of glial cells (mainly microglia and astrocytes) and expression of key inflammatory mediators as well as neurotoxic free radicals. Not much is known so far about the role of neuroinflammation in TS. However, this tic disorder shows a lot of pathophysiological parallels to other psychiatric diseases (e.g. considering the neurotransmitter dysbalance). It has been suggested that neuroinflammation is associated with neurodegenerative disorders—both acute (e.g. stroke, injury) and chronic (e.g. multiple sclerosis, Alzheimer’s disease). In this context, microglia cells play a crucial role and therefore microglia and cytokines have been extensively studied in these conditions. In the CNS, microglia are the resident phagocytes of the innate immune system. In an activated state, microglia produce various pro-inflammatory cytokines and other immune mediators that create a neurotoxic milieu leading to disease progression [34, 35]. Microglia are one of three glial cell types in the CNS. They play an important role as immunocompetent and phagocytic cells in the event of injury and disease. Del Rio Hortega determined in 1927 that microglia belong to a distinct glial cell type apart from astrocytes and oligodendrocytes [36]. Since the 1970s there has been wide recognition that microglia are immune effectors in the CNS that respond to pathological conditions and participate in initiation and progression of neurological and psychiatric disorders by releasing potentially cytotoxic molecules such as pro-inflammatory cytokines, reactive oxygen intermediates, proteinases, and complement proteins [37]. This means that their phagocytic function can be beneficial while their inflammation related functions might be detrimental for neuropsychiatric diseases.

A probable mechanism of how infections can influence the cerebral immune balance could be the activation of the tryptophan catabolism via infectious agents and elevated proinflammatory cytokines [9]. In the CNS tryptophan degradation takes place especially in microglia (also partly in astrocytes and neurons). The essential amino acid tryptophan gets degraded either to serotonin or over the kynurenine pathway (KP) to other products [10], which function either as a NMDA- receptor agonist or antagonist and control the neurotransmitter availability [11]. The activation of this KP has been shown to play an important role in the pathophysiology of neuropsychiatric disorders (e.g. schizophrenia) [38]. Also for TS, Behen et al. have identified in an imaging study that TS patients have an abnormal tryptophan metabolism in the cortical and subcortical area [12].

Considering the involvement of neuroinflammation in the course of TS, it strengthens the association between infectious agents activating the tryptophan breakdown either directly or through resulting pro-inflammatory cytokines and therefore influencing the neurotransmitter balance.

NEW THERAPEUTIC OPTIONS FOR TOURETTE’S SYNDROME

In TS several immunologic changes have been identified. Therefore the question of a possible therapy targeting specific immune parameters has been raised. This idea is further strengthened by the finding of auto-antibodies in TS. Zykov et al. showed that antibodies to caudate nucleus proteins were detected in patients with Tourette’s syndrome (the caudate nucleus is a structure, which is functionally important for the appearance of hyperkinesias). The detection of neuroantibodies suggests the possible participation of autoimmune mechanisms in the pathogenesis of this disease [39]. The presence of neuroantibodies could be an evidence for impairment of the functions of the blood-brain barrier, which regulates the release of elements of neural structures into the bloodstream, their contact with immune system cells, and the transport of neuroantibodies to the CNS and subsequent influencing the neurotransmitter balance. The precise mechanism of the appearance of autoimmune processes in various nervous system diseases remains a subject of investigation and still it is unclear whether these autoimmune processes are consistently part of TS pathology. So far studies remain controversial: Brilot et al. found serum autoantibodies that bind to neuronal cell surface antigens are present in Sydenham chorea but not in PANDAS or TS. The findings of this group weaken the autoantibody hypothesis in PANDAS and TS [40].

Thus, is the observation of antibodies to caudate nucleus proteins a justification to treat TS patients with immunoglobulins? First studies are showing positive effects after the administration of immunoglobulins to patients with TS in the treatment of tic-type hyperkinesias and provide evidence of the involvement of autoimmune mechanisms inducing damage to the dopaminergic system of the striatum. One case report demonstrated that a 14-year-old boy with TS, familial susceptibility, and an increase in the antibody titer of streptococcal antigens was treated with 75 immunoglobulins i.v. over 5 days. Response to this therapy was good regarding motor tics, vocal tics, and behavioural symptoms such as disturbed impulse control which still persisted after 9 months [41].

Other studies addressed the possibility of using immunoglobulins for intravenous administration and plasma exchange in the treatment of TS. Perlmutter et al. wanted to test if post-streptococcal autoimmunity is the cause of the tic exacerbations. In this case, children might respond to immunomodulatory treatments. Patients received either plasma exchange or i.v. immunoglobulins or i.v. placebo. The authors found that the i.v. immunoglobulin group and the plasma-exchange group showed striking improvements in obsessive-compulsive symptoms, anxiety and overall functioning. Tic symptoms were also significantly improved by plasma exchange compared to placebo. The treatment gains were maintained at one year, with 82% of children “much” or “very much” improved over baseline [42].

The long-term effects of the i.v. immunoglobulins might be associated with the immunomodulatory actions of normal antibodies on T-lymphocytes and macrophages, as well as B-lymphocyte functions and their regulatory actions on the membrane-damaging components of the complement system. Therefore the suggestion that autoimmune mechanisms are involved in the pathogenesis of tic-type hyperkinesias might allow widening of the therapeutic approach to TS in the future.

Taken this together, immunotherapy can be effective in a case in which antibodies to caudate nucleus proteins are detected, which is evidence for the pathogenetic approach of this therapy and further supports the hypothesis that there is an autoimmune variant of tic-type hyperkinesias. However, data on these therapies remains very limited and maybe these new therapeutic options are only applicable to a subset of TS patients.

The discussed infectious and immunologic abnormalities in TS indicate that infectious agents and immune parameters might influence the cerebral neurotransmitter balance via the tryptophan catabolism. The association of infections and the kynurenic pathway could have therapeutic implications, as at present inhibitors of certain metabolites of this pathway are available [9].

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

The authors confirm that this article content has no conflicts of interest.

REFERENCES