Neurofilamentopathy in Neurodegenerative Diseases
Quan Liu1, Fang Xie2, Abdiel Alvarado-Diaz3, Mark A Smith4, Paula I Moreira5, Xiongwei Zhu4, George Perry*, 6
Identifiers and Pagination:Year: 2011
First Page: 58
Last Page: 62
Publisher Id: TONEUJ-5-58
Article History:Received Date: 12/6/2011
Revision Received Date: 25/7/2011
Acceptance Date: 28/7/2011
Electronic publication date: 26/8/2011
Collection year: 2011
open-access license: This is an open access article licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted, non-commercial use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the work is properly cited.
Neurofilament protein alterations are found in many neurodegenerative diseases, such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, Parkinson, Alzheimer, and Charcot-Marie-Tooth. Abnormal modifications of neurofilament, such as mutation, oxidation and phosphorylation, are linked to the disease-related alteration. In this review, the most recent discovery and central arguments about functions, pathological modifications, and genetic mutations related to neurofilaments in neurodegenerative diseases is presented.
Neurofilaments are intermediate filaments in neurons composed of three subunits, NFH, NFM, and NFL (Neurofilament heavy, medium, and light subunits). Primarily expressed in neurons, neurofilament proteins are major components in large myelinated axons, e.g. sciatic and optic nerves. Abnormal accumulation of neurofilament is a primary finding in many human neurodegenerative disorders, including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, Parkinson, Alzheimer, Charcot-Marie-Tooth, dementia with Lewy bodies [1, 2], and toxic neuropathy . Many alterations can potentially lead to accumulation of neurofilaments, including mutation, disregulation of neurofilament protein synthesis, defective axonal transport, and abnormal phosphorylation/glycosylation/ oxidation . Neurofilament abnormality in neurodegenerative disorders is a hallmark of neuronal dysfunction, especially marking axonal degeneration.
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
A major pathological hallmark of ALS is intraneuronal accumulation of phosphorylated neurofilament proteins in degenerating motor neurons [5-7]. The neurofilament protein accumulations are characterized by forming initially in the distal axon and retrogradly transported to the cell body, correlated with severity of disease. Neurofilament gene expression patterns are altered in ALS, suggesting NF subunit ratio could be important .
Singly overexpressing any of the neurofilament subunits (NFL, NFM or NFH) in transgenic mice led to prominent motor neuropathy characterized by the presence of abnormal neurofilament accumulations resembling those found in ALS [9-11]. Restoring a correct stoichiometry of human NFL to NF-H subunits with the co-expression of human NFL transgene in transgenic mice overexpressing human NFH rescues the motor neuropathy . Similar changes in stoichometry may occur in diseases as NFL mRNA is selectively reduced by up to 70% in degenerating neurons of ALS and AD [13, 14].
Studies by Lobsiger and colleagues  showed genetic elimination of NFM and NFH tail domains and their 58 known phosphorylation sites in SOD1 mutant mice accelerates aberrant phosphorylation of other neuronal substrates while leaving overall neurofilament content unaltered. The disease onset is significantly delayed and survival is extended in mice, which indicates that abnormal phosphorylation may be a detrimental factor.
Studies by Ludemann et al.,  showed that in spinal cord tissue of a transgenic rat model for ALS, O-linked N-acetylglucosamine immunoreactivity of neurofilament proteins is strongly decreased compared with wild-type animals while phosphorylation is increased, suggesting competition of the binding sites of these two modifications and a potential mechanism for the formation of neurofilament protein accumulations in ALS.
Pin1 associates with phosphorylated NFH in neurons and is colocalized in ALS-affected spinal cord neuronal inclusions . Inhibition of Pin1 activity by inhibitor or down-regulating Pin1 levels through siRNA rescued neurons from glutamate-induced cell death. The authors suggest that Pin1 inhibition may be a therapeutic target to reduce pathological accumulations of p-NFH
More recently, the possible involvement of dynein/ dynactin in ALS has also been explored. Teuling and colleagues  generated transgenic mice with neuron specific expression of Bicaudal D2 N-terminus (BICD2-N) to chronically impair dynein/dynactin function and their results showed that BICD2-N mice did not develop signs of motor neuron degeneration and motor abnormalities even with apparent abnormalities. Also this transgene increased life span in SOD1-G93A ALS transgenic mice. They concluded that impaired dynein/dynactin function may be part of the ALS phenotype although further work is clearly called for to clarify the mechanism.
Cheroni and colleagues  demonstrated impairment of the ubiquitin proteasome system (UPS) in lumbar spinal cord in double transgenic mice expressing the familial ALS superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) gene mutation G93A (SOD1G93A). They showed that one third of the cells with accumulation of the UPS reporter substrate also displayed an accumulation of phosphorylated neurofilaments (SM1-31), like those normally present only in axons. In line with this, they report that not all the ventral horn neurons showing reporter gene immunoreactivity also accumulated phosphorylated neurofilaments or ubiquitin, two markers of degeneration in ALS.
The possibility that not only post-translational changes of NF subunits are promoting neurofilamentopathy has also been addressed. Volkening and colleagues  examined the interactions of TDP-43, 14-3-3 and SOD1 proteins with NFL mRNA 3’UTR due to their potential to directly affect the stability of NFL transcripts. When ALS spinal cord motor neurons were assessed, it appeared that TDP-43 can be sequestered into translationally quiescent granules as either stress and degradative granules in a manner consistent with the relocalization of TDP-43 under neuronal stress. Their findings suggest that a greater proportion of NFL may be targeted for translational silencing and/or degradation in ALS. Interestingly, mice lacking neurofilament expression show delayed disease onset from mutant SOD1 .
Brettschneider and colleagues  reported a 5-fold increase of NFH level in CSF samples of ALS patients compared to controls, suggesting NFH level can be a marker of axonal damage. Kuhle and collaborators  validated a new electrochemiluminescence (ECL) immunoassay for the neurofilament heavy chain protein using SMI-35 antibody, showing that their ECL based assay resulted in superior sensitivity, precision and accuracy, further opening the field to neurofilament-based biomarkers.
Alzheimer Disease (AD)
Neurofibrillary tangles, one of the hallmarks of AD, are composed of abnormally modified tau protein, plus neurofilament proteins, ubiquitin and other cytoskeleton proteins [27, 28]. Studies agree that tau protein and neurofilament proteins found in neurofibrillary tangles are extensively phosphorylated, especially in some sites not seen in the physiological state, which is likely due to perturbation in the balance between kinase and phosphatase activities [29-32].
Neurofilament protein expression levels are altered in AD . In addition, oxidative markers are highly concentrated in the lesions of AD and in neurofilament proteins of axons whether in AD or controls [34-36]. Pamplona and colleagues  showed elevation of all markers of oxidation, particularly those of reactive aldehydes from glycoxidation and lipoxidation that react with lysine residues on proteins in brain cortex samples from Alzheimer patients using GC-mass spectrometry. Modifications involve neurofilaments, tubulin, and others.
The presence of neurofilament proteins and their phosphorylation sites in neurites of senile plaques were also examined , where they show novel phosphorylation sites on NFL. They suggest the complexity and possible role of the neurofilament in the formation of senile plaques.
Deng and colleagues  demonstrated that O-GlcNAcylation and phosphorylation of NFM regulate each other reciprocally in cultured neuroblastoma cells and in metabolically active rat brain slices. In animal models of fasting rats, they found a decrease in O-GlcNAcylation and increase in phosphorylation of NFM. They also observed decreased O-GlcNAcylation and an increased phosphorylation of NFM in AD brain. These results suggest that O-GlcNAcylation and phosphorylation of NF-M were regulated reciprocally and that the hyperphosphorylation and accumulation of NF-M in AD brain might be caused by impaired brain glucose uptake/metabolism via down-regulation of NF-M O-GlcNAcylation.
Björkdahl and colleagues  showed that overexpression of the chaperonin proteins Hsp27 or alphaB-crystallin in N2a cells could increase or decrease phosphorylation level of tau and NF. Expression of Hsp27 and alphaB-crystallin in AD brain samples were increased by 20% and 30% respectively, which correlated significantly with phosphorylated tau and NF proteins.
Using ELISA and antibodies to tau and NFH, Brettschneider and colleagues  reported that NFH protein increased 10 fold in AD patient CSF samples compared to controls. They suggested that NFH level in CSF could be used as a marker for axonal damage, much as tau has been suggested as a marker for neuronal damage.
The role of neurofibrillary tangles and senile plaques in AD is under intensive debate . Some researchers believe that protein accumulation in various polymeric and monomeric forms is the initial cause of the disease, and others think such accumulation is the response to the initial insult, which results in different approaches in development of therapeutics. Significant protein accumulation is a response to oxidative damage occurring with aging, [35, 41]. Therefore, preventing oxidative damage may provide a useful intervention to reduce neurofilament protein abnormalities.
Recently, Thangavel  and collaborators described a negative relation between SMI-32 immunoreactivity, non-phosphorylated neurofilament, and AT8, an antibody against hyperphosphorylated tau, in specific brain areas. Neurons expressing non-phosphorylated neurofilaments in temporal cortical areas were susceptible to early degeneration in AD and the vulnerability of these SMI32 positive subpopulations of pyramidal cells in AD is associated with co-expression of abnormally phosphorylated tau protein, suggesting a complex interplay between tau and neurofilament phosphorylation [43, 44].
Knowing the distribution and co-localization of other neurofilament-related proteins is also important to understanding the neurofilamentopathy in AD. Sonoda and colleagues  demonstrated the phosphatase and tensin homologue on chromosome 10 (PTEN), linked to AD, functions both as a tyrosine phosphatase and lipid phosphatase and is colocalized with abnormal tau and phosphorylated neurofilament proteins in neurons. These findings suggest that redistribution of PTEN to neuritic pathology may be significant in the formation of tau and neurofilament pathology in AD brains.
Parkinson Disease (PD)
PD is marked by degeneration of the pigmented neurons in the substantia nigra resulting in decreased dopamine secretion. Lewy bodies, the major pathological change of PD, and found in the degenerating neurons, are an inclusion composed of numerous proteins including α-synuclein, three neurofilament subunits, ubiquitin and proteasome subunits, torsinA and parkin [46, 47], some of which are genetically linked to the disease [48-51].
A proteomic analysis of substantia nigra samples from PD patients showed reduced protein level of NFM and NFL in brain of PD patients, and an elevated oxidative-state cellular environment was also confirmed . NFL mRNA is also decreased, correlating with the severity of the disease of PD .
An early onset (age 16) PD patient showed a point mutation in the region of the NEFM gene coding for the rod domain 2B of NFM . The base pair change results in substitution of serine for glycine at residue 336, and was argued to disrupt neurofilament assembly . This NFEM gene mutation was screened in another 322 PD patients and none were found . Han and colleagues  re-screened an additional 102 PD patients and 45 controls for this single base pair substitution (G1747A) mutation of the NFEM gene, which was reported by Lavedan and colleagues . No mutation was found.
Abdo and colleagues  examined the differences of patients with idiopathic Parkinson's disease from patients with multiple system atrophy predominated by parkinsonism (MSA-P) using multiple protein markers. They showed that CSF levels of NFL, NFH, and tau were significantly increased in MSA-P.
Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease (CMT)
CMT is the most common inherited neurological disorder and it is generally inherited in an autosomal dominant pattern. CMT affects both motor neurons and sensory neurons to the muscles, and patients slowly lose function of their feet/legs and hands/arms as nerves to the extremities degenerate.
Several mutations of the NEFL gene on chromosome 8 are associated with CMT2 including a proline to glutamine at residue 8, a proline-to-serine substitution at codon 22, leucine to proline at residue 333, leucine to proline at residue 394 [59-64]. Jordanova and colleagues  also found six pathogenic missense mutations and one 3-bp inframe deletion in the NFL gene in 323 patients with different CMT phenotypes.
Recently, Sasaki and colleagues  showed that Pro22Ser mutations abolished Thr21 phosphorylation by cyclin-dependent kinase 5 and external signal regulated kinase, which suppressed filament assembly, but phosphorylation by protein kinase A (PKA) inhibited aggregate formation in vitro and alleviated aggregates in cortical neurons. These results indicate that the Pro22Ser CMT mutation induces abnormal filament accumulation by disrupting proper oligomer formation and the aggregates are mitigated by phosphorylation with PKA, which makes it a viable target for the development of therapeutics.
Further examination of three mutations in the NFL gene P22S, P8R, Q333P, in cell culture,  showed these mutations affect the axonal transport of mutant and wild-type neurofilaments. They also affected the transport of mitochondria and human amyloid β protein precursor; resulting in alterations of retrograde axonal transport, fragmentation of the Golgi apparatus, and increased neuritic degeneration.
Zhai and colleagues  investigated the role of aggregation of NFL protein in the neurotoxicity of CMT mutant NFL and CMT mutant HSPB1 in motor neurons, which cause neuron death. They found that expression of wild type HSPB1 could remediate the progressive degeneration and loss of neuronal viability. Hull and colleagues , using a mouse muscle cell line expressing chimeric neurofilament (NF) proteins, found reduced cell viability and activated caspases, which mimic the pathology of CMT and may be a useful cell model for future studies to investigate the mechanism responsible for NFL disruption. These studies support the view that aggregation of NFL is a common triggering event of motor neuron degeneration in CMT.
Moreover, Zhu and colleagues  described how both increases and decreases in the phosphorylation of neurofilament network are modulated by multisynthetase complex p43 (MSC p43). Their results determine that overexpression of MSC p43 led to a decreased level of neurofilament protein phosphorylation, whereas MSC p43 depletion caused hyperphosphorylation of neurofilament proteins and neurofilament network disassembly in primary cultured neurons and motor axons. Further assays using MSC p43-Null mice show similar phenotypic traits shared with CMT neuropathy type 2D, such as loss of large diameter axons from both motor and sensory peripheral nerves, distal motor neuropathy with impairment in synaptic connectivity at neuro-muscular junctions, and muscle denervation in the hind limb.
The role of neurofilaments was further clarified by using double transgenic mice, hNF-LP22S; that model CMT2E . They suggest CMT pathology is mostly unrelated to the NF accumulation in the cell bodies, as they found normal NF density in axons but instead decreased density of microtubules. The effects of hNF-LP22S could arise from cytoskeletal alterations that provoke axonal transport defects due to microtubule abnormalities. These findings highlight the close interrelationship of cytoskeletal systems.
Neurofilament abnormalities have been directly or indirectly demonstrated in multiple neurodegerative diseases. The removal of the protein aggregates with different approaches is an area of intense interest. In spite of whether these protein aggregates were the cause or the consequence of these diseases, neurofilament abnormalities are a critical factor in the cellular disruption in a number of neurodegenerative diseases. Understanding the characteristics, the mechanism of the formation, and approaches to modulate neurofilament abnormalities is central to monitoring and developing efficacious therapeutics.